BenefitBeacon

← All tools

Rent vs Buy Calculator

Working

A rent vs buy calculator compares the monthly cost of renting a home with the monthly cost of owning a comparable home, using figures you put in for both sides. Renting has one number — the monthly rent. Buying has several: the mortgage payment, property tax, homeowners insurance, and maintenance. It adds up the buying side, compares it with the rent, and works out the monthly difference either way. It also estimates a break-even time: the upfront cost of buying, divided by the monthly amount buying saves you, if it saves you anything. What you get is a comparison, not a recommendation — renting and buying differ in more than money, and the right answer depends on how long you'll stay, how stable your income is, and how much you value flexibility.

Illustration comparing a monthly rent figure with a monthly buying cost, representing the rent versus buy decision.

A common planning figure for maintenance is about 1 percent of the home price per year, divided by 12 — $250 a month on a $300,000 home. Enter your own estimate.

How this is calculated

The comparison is built from figures you put in. The monthly mortgage payment uses the standard amortization formula: M = P × r(1+r)n ÷ ((1+r)n − 1), where P is the loan amount (home price minus down payment), r is the monthly interest rate, and n is the number of monthly payments. The total monthly cost of buying is that mortgage payment plus the monthly property tax, homeowners insurance and maintenance you put in. The monthly difference is rent minus the total buying cost: a positive number means buying is cheaper month to month, a negative one means renting is cheaper. The break-even time is the upfront cost of buying — down payment plus the other upfront costs you enter, such as closing costs — divided by the monthly saving from buying, converted to years: break-even years = upfront buying costs ÷ monthly saving ÷ 12. If buying does not save anything month to month, there is no break-even point, and it says so.

Source

The mortgage payment uses the standard amortization formula, and the comparison is standard arithmetic on user-entered figures. Home-buying guidance is published by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau at consumerfinance.gov/owning-a-home/, and housing guidance by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development at hud.gov.

Limitations

It compares monthly cash costs only, and it does not predict the future. In real terms, it does not include rent increases over time, home price changes, the equity you build by paying down the loan, tax effects, selling costs, or the cost of your time spent on maintenance. It does not include mortgage insurance, which a lender commonly requires below 20 percent down, or homeowners association dues. The break-even figure treats the whole down payment as a cost, even though the down payment becomes equity in the home — so it is a conservative figure, not a full financial analysis. Use it to compare monthly costs, not as a decision on its own.

What this tool does

Renting and buying look similar from the outside — both give you a place to live for a monthly amount — but the monthly amounts are made of different things, and the comparison is easy to get wrong. Rent is one number. Buying is a mortgage payment plus tax plus insurance plus maintenance, and the mortgage payment itself depends on the price, the down payment, the rate and the term. This rent vs buy calculator puts both sides on the same footing: the rent you would pay for a comparable home, against the full monthly cost of owning one. It also answers the follow-up question, which is usually the one that matters: if buying is cheaper month to month, how long does it take for the monthly saving to cover the large upfront cost of buying? And if buying is more expensive month to month, it says so plainly, so you're not misled by a comparison that only looked at the mortgage payment and ignored tax, insurance and upkeep.

Your inputs, explained

Monthly rent should be the rent for a home comparable to the one you would buy — same area, similar size — not the cheapest rent you can find. Home price, down payment, interest rate and term work the same way as in a down payment calculation: the price minus the down payment is the loan, and the rate and term set the monthly mortgage payment. Monthly property tax is the annual tax bill divided by 12; county tax records and listing pages usually show the annual figure. Monthly homeowners insurance is the annual premium divided by 12. Monthly maintenance is your estimate for repairs and upkeep — a common planning figure is about 1 percent of the home price per year, or $250 a month on a $300,000 home, though older homes often cost more. Other upfront costs covers closing costs and similar one-off buying costs, on top of the down payment. Years you expect to stay sets the horizon for the totals shown; the longer you stay, the more the comparison favors buying, because the upfront cost is spread over more months.

How to read your result

Start with the two monthly totals: the rent, and the full monthly cost of buying. The difference between them is the headline — which side costs less each month, and by how much. Then look at the totals over the years you expect to stay: they show how the monthly gap adds up, before the upfront cost. The break-even figure ties the two together. It is the upfront cost divided by the monthly saving, in years. If the break-even time is longer than you expect to stay, buying does not pay for itself on monthly costs within your stay — though you would still own the equity, which this comparison doesn't count as a return. If there is no break-even because buying costs more each month, the result says so, and the honest reading is that renting is cheaper on cash flow for the figures entered. Remember that the down payment becomes equity, so the break-even shown here is conservative; a fuller analysis would credit you for the equity built, but it would also have to allow for selling costs and the risk that prices fall.

Worked example

Take a rent of $2,500 a month and a $300,000 home with 20 percent down, a 6 percent rate and a 30-year term. The down payment is $60,000 and the loan is $240,000, giving a monthly mortgage payment of $1,438.92. Add property tax of $250, insurance of $120 and maintenance of $150, and the total monthly cost of buying is $1,958.92 — a saving of $541.08 a month against the rent. The upfront cost is the $60,000 down payment plus $4,000 of other upfront costs, or $64,000. Divide $64,000 by $541.08 a month and the break-even is 118.3 months, or 9.9 years — far longer than most people stay in one home, because the down payment is so large relative to the monthly saving. A second check shows the other direction: a rent of $1,800 against a $350,000 home with 20 percent down at 6.5 percent over 30 years. In practice, the mortgage payment is $1,769.79, and with $300 of tax, $150 of insurance and $200 of maintenance the total buying cost is $2,419.79 — $619.79 a month more than renting, so there is no break-even at all. Each of these was worked out by hand and matches it.

Common questions

Is renting always throwing money away?

No. Rent buys housing with no maintenance, no property tax bill, no large upfront cost, and the freedom to move. Buying builds equity, but it also carries maintenance, taxes, insurance, selling costs, and the risk that prices fall. In real terms, the right choice depends on how long you will stay and how the monthly numbers compare — which is what this calculator shows.

Why is the break-even time so long in the example?

Because the upfront cost includes the whole down payment, and the monthly saving is only a few hundred dollars. A $64,000 upfront cost divided by $541 a month is about 118 years. The down payment isn't spent — it becomes equity in the home — so the break-even here is deliberately conservative. It is a warning against treating buying as a quick saving, not a full return calculation.

Should I include rent increases in the comparison?

Over a long stay, rents usually rise while a fixed-rate mortgage payment stays the same, which favors buying over time. This calculator does not model rent increases, so for a stay of many years the comparison understates the case for buying. Test it by entering a higher rent and seeing how the result changes.

What costs does this tool leave out?

Mortgage insurance (commonly required below 20 percent down), homeowners association dues, selling costs when you move, tax effects, and any change in the home's value. It also leaves out the equity you build. Treat the result as a monthly-cost comparison, and get a lender's estimate for the full picture before deciding.

Sources

Check the figures, rules and application steps with the agency that runs the program. Only the sources below have a verified address in this draft.

Related guides

Official sources

Benefit rules, amounts and application steps come from the administering agency. These links open the official agency home page in a new tab. Program pages link to the agency named on the page.